Those Scythian Bongs Don’t Exist

Those 2400-year-old solid-gold bongs unearthed in southern Russia – not actual things. Scythians never smoked bongs because no Scythian bongs ever existed.

What Scythians did do is burn cannabis using braziers. Fumigation with cannabis – or ‘hotboxing’, if you prefer – was a Scythian custom we know was practiced during their funeral rites. Historical and archaeological evidence for this exists in Book IV of the Histories of Herodotus, a kurgan at Pazyryk in the Altai, and a burial ground in the eastern Pamirs – though the latter did not yield up any of the tripod ‘hotboxing’ tents found in the Histories and at Pazyryk.

Cannabis was perhaps also ‘smoked’ recreationally in and around Central Asia by simply throwing the plants onto bonfires, as the Histories describes with an unknown plant and unknown people on a river Herodotus calls the Araxes, which may possibly be the Syr Darya (Jaxartes) of today’s Uzbekistan.

But what we know for sure is cannabis smoke was employed sacramentally by Scythians, and now, thanks to the so-called ‘bong’ finds, that opiated cannabis drinks were brewed in solid gold vessels, apparently to be drunk from equally exquisite gold cups by the staggeringly wealthy, immensely powerful Scythian elites of the Pontic–Caspian Steppe.

History’s original dope fiends, these Scythians were ethnolinguistically northern Iranian peoples whose settled and nomadic cultures spanned from what are now Ukraine and Turkey to northwest India, Mongolia, and the frontiers of the Central Chinese Plain. Throughout the Iron Age, Scythian federations dominated much of Eurasia, in some reckonings not just shaping but giving rise to the Axial Age – the birth of civilisation as we understand it and the era of luminaries such as Buddha, Plato, and Lao Tzu. It’s been argued Gautama Buddha and even Lao Tzu were Scythians themselves. True or not, that’s a reminder that not every ethnic Scythian was a pot smoker, kind of the same way that not every Jamaican is a Rasta or every Indian a sadhu of the Juna Akhara. Many Scythians, incidentally, likely wore dreads.

All of which is great….

But there’s no such thing as a Scythian bong. Unless, that is, you’re online and reading the Daily Mail, Daily Expressetcetcetc… or world’s worst source of cannabis information, Wikipedia. In which case, Scythian bongs are totally real. FACT!

Not exactly…

Fact is the Scythian bong is just another instance of unreality and how it multiplies online.

Born shortly after the May 22nd 2015 publication in National Geographic of an article by Andrew Curry entitled Gold Artifacts Tell Tale of Drug-Fuelled Rituals and “Bastard Wars”, Scythian bongs undertook a rapid, thoroughly Scythian conquest of the expanses of the Internet.

Note that “shortly after”, because nowhere in Curry’s article is there any mention of bongs. All the bong claims are from clickbait published by cynical UK tabloids that caught wind of his National Geographic article.

Meanwhile, back in reality, Curry’s expert source is the archaeologist Andrei Belinski, who in summer 2013 unearthed astonishing gold treasure from a Scythian kurgan in the steppe grasslands of Stavropolski Krai, southern Russia. It’s these gold objects that provide one part of the material basis for the otherwise entirely imaginary 2400-year-old Scythian bongs….

Exquisite as it is, this gold treasure in fact comprises two vessels and three small gold cups, plus a heavy gold ring and armbands. No bongs. No pipes. Not even any braziers. “The chamber contained two bucket-shaped gold vessels, each placed upside down. Inside were three gold cups.…” The so-called ‘bongs’, these cups showed “no sign of charring or burning.” Belinski speculates that “they were used to brew and drink a strong opium concoction.”

Enter a “black residue” inside the vessels, which is the second fragment of objectively verifiable reality out of which the Scythian bongs fantasy was born. Sent to a criminology lab, this black residue tested positive for “opium and cannabis.” This is the basis for Belinski’s speculation about ‘smoking’. His guess is that “cannabis was burning nearby.” That’s a guess based partly on the Histories’ account of Scythian cannabis fumigation and partly, it seems, on an assumption by Belinski that cannabis is not a drug that is drunk.

Because a much more straightforward explanation for this black residue containing traces of opium and cannabis is that – you guessed it – the brew contained opium and cannabis.

These gold drinking vessels for opium and cannabis belonged to the nobility of a Scythian nation of the southern Pontic–Caspian Steppe. With their hordes circling just north of the Caucasus mountains, these Scythian federations amassed their wealth through Black Sea trade with Greeks and by plundering the settled urban civilizations of the Middle East, where Scythian clans operated as mercenaries and power-brokers, at times seizing control of whole kingdoms and forging empires. That history is told in Herodotus and – if Belinski is right – one of its episodes, the Bastard Wars, is depicted on these very vessels.

As argued by another archaeologist, Andrew Sherratt, not to smoke but to drink cannabis – in imitation of the wine of the affluent, urbane cultures of the Levant and Mesopotamia – is exactly what you’d expect in this elite context.

***

Today, this same paradigm persists in attitudes toward drinking versus smoking cannabis in South Asia, where the one high-status or socially accepted form of cannabis product is bhang, in sharp contrast to the widely frowned-upon smoked forms, charas and ganja.

6 responses to “Those Scythian Bongs Don’t Exist

  1. Pingback: Endangered Varieties of subsp. indica: A Few Thoughts | The Real Seed Company: The Honest Online Source for Cannabis Landraces Est. 2007·

  2. Pingback: Cannabis & Alchemy Podcast Episodes | The Real Seed Company: The Honest Online Source for Cannabis Landraces Est. 2007·

    • Thanks Chris, good to see you here.

      re. “people think i don’t know what i’m talking about when i tell them there were no scythian bongs.”

      It’s a safe bet that these very same people won’t believe anything in old-fashioned mainstream news media and – if it suits them – probably reject science too….

      Meanwhile, if trash tabloids and crappo websites tell them what they want to hear or they like the sound of, they’ll swallow it hook line and sinker…

      It’s one of those weird paradoxes of conspiracy thinking and the paranoid mode, especially in the age of the internet –

      That strange blend of cynicism and gullibility….

      Believe nothing and you’ll believe anything!

  3. The problem with both the bong and this theory for how these gold objects were used is the objects themselves. The “tubing” is solid-there is no place for liquid to flow through. The “cups” have holes in the bottom-any liquid would have drained out! It is much more likely that they were used as an individual inverted smoke concentrator that could be used to suck cannabis smoke-sort of like an upside down pipe bowl..

    • Thanks for this comment Dr. DeRose!

      It’s been in the back of my mind that there might be a better explanation for what’s going on with these devices –

      Not least, because of this point re. holes in the ‘cups’ and larger ‘vessels’

      But note that the ‘tubing’ is certainly some very posh gold armbands

      Anyway – as your idea implies, there’s context for a possible smoking set-up

      A ‘chasing the dragon’ type method is commonly used for smoking charas (cannabis resin) and opium in places such as Chitral and Afghanistan, as well as Iran

      A piece of resin is placed on hot coals and then a tube (eg rolled paper) is used to catch and inhale the smoke

      In C19 Iran, this was known as the ‘pipe of unity’ – a reference to Sufi teachings

      I have smoked in this way with friends from Chitral many times

      You can see demonstrations of smoking from coals at this page, which belongs to an Afghan friend of mine.

      I think the jury is still out, as they could well be part of a set for brewing and straining bhang / opium brews as per this image – but if I had to bet on it, I might be tempted to go with your idea of smoking devices

      Update to add that Prof James McHugh noted as follows – criminology lab is a suspect choice for an archaeologist, plus best solution to all this would be to ask an expert on cups and the like of this era and region

      Thanks again, Angus

Leave a reply to Chris Bennett Cancel reply